Movies DVDs Music Books Comix TV Games HWJ Blogs
Contact Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Subscribe | About

Title Search: Advanced Search
         
 
Silver City is John Sayles' comment on the state of the political process. Among the things he wants to show us is that the marketing of a candidate takes precedence over substance so candidates like Pilager learn quickly to avoid having to speak extemporaneously or to answer surprise questions.

(2004) Film Review

This page was created on October 20, 2004
This page was last updated on December 11, 2004


Review by Darrel Manson
Trailers, Photos
About this Film
Blog with Darrel Manson


Dial up modems will take a few moments

CREDITS

Click to enlargeDirected by John Sayles
Written by John Sayles

Cast (in credits order)
Maria Bello .... Nora Allardyce
Thora Birch .... Karen Cross
David Clennon .... Mort Seymour
Chris Cooper .... Dickie Pilager
Alma Delfina .... Lupe Montoya
Richard Dreyfuss .... Chuck Raven
Miguel Ferrer .... Cliff Castleton
James Gammon .... Sheriff Joe Skaggs
Daryl Hannah .... Maddy Pilager
Danny Huston .... Danny O'Brien
Kris Kristofferson .... Wes Benteen
Sal Lopez .... Tony Guerra
Michael Murphy .... Senator Judson Pilager
Mary Kay Place .... Grace Seymour
Tim Roth .... Mitch Paine
Luis Saguar .... Vince Esparza
Ralph Waite .... Casey Lyle
Billy Zane .... Chandler Tyson

Produced by
Suzanne Ceresko .... associate producer
Maggie Renzi .... producer
Sam Tedesco .... associate producer

Original Music by Mason Daring
Cinematography by Haskell Wexler
Film Editing by John Sayles

MPAA: Rated R for language.
Runtime: 129 min

For rating reasons, go to FILMRATINGS.COM, and MPAA.ORG.
Parents, please refer to PARENTALGUIDE.ORG

TRAILERS AND CLIPS
Trailers, Photos
POSTER 
Search For Posters!
AVAILABILITY ON VIDEO AND DVD

CHECK AVAILABILITY AND PRICING OF THIS MOVIE ON VIDEO OR DVD.
Just type in movie title and click go.

Also, check out 100 Hot Videos
and the 100 Hot DVDs

 
SYNOPSIS
From John Sayles, one of the essential, iconoclastic voices of American independent cinema, comes "Silver City," a film that is equal parts scathing political lampoon and sun-stunned neo-noir detective story. Set against the backdrop of a mythic "New West," "Silver City" follows grammatically-challenged, "user-friendly" candidate Dicky Pilager (Cooper), scapegrace scion of Colorado's venerable Senator Jud Pilager (Murphy), during his gubernatorial campaign. When Pilager finds that he's reeled in a corpse during the taping of an environmental political ad, his ferocious campaign manager, Chuck Raven (Dreyfuss), hires former idealistic journalist turned rumpled private detective Danny O'Brien (Huston) to investigate potential links between the corpse and the Pilager family's enemies. In the tradition of the great films noir, Danny’s investigation pulls him deeper and deeper into a complex web of influence and corruption, involving high stakes lobbyists, media conglomerates, environmental plunderers, and undocumented migrant workers. With pitch-perfect dialogue, unerring sense-of-place, and a slashing satiric strain, "Silver City" offers John Sayles's timely and toxic look at the state of the union on the eve of the 2004 Presidential election.
Review by DARREL MANSON
Pastor, Artesia Christian Church, Artesia, CA
http://netministries.org/see/churches/ch01198

Darrel has an incredible love and interest in the cinematic arts. His reviews usually include independent and significantly important film.
Click to enlargeDicky Pilager is running for Governor in Colorado. One would be naive indeed not to recognize that Pilager's character is designed as a George W. Bush clone. He's the latest generation of a political dynasty. He is very good when on script, but on his own, his mouth will get him in serious trouble. He doesn't seem very bright (although a sham website makes the point that his GPA was higher than President Bush's). He's very closely tied to big business. On top of all this, Chris Cooper seems to be "channeling" the President in his portrayal of the candidate, and the comparison is not meant to be flattering to the President.

Silver City is John Sayles' comment on the state of the political process. Among the things he wants to show us is that the marketing of a candidate takes precedence over substance so candidates like Pilager learn quickly to avoid having to speak extemporaneously or to answer surprise questions. Instead they learn to stay "on message," that is, to say only what they plan to say, especially if it fits into a sound bite.

Click to enlargeSayles' films often deal with appearances as opposed to reality. Prime examples are Lone Star and Sunshine State. Here, too, it's clear that Sayles is showing us a public image of a politician while letting us know that the real person is quite different. On camera or in prepared events, Pilager looks and sounds strong and confident. In a scene with reporters but no handler, he is obviously incapable of serious problem solving.

The film does have some important points to make. Unfortunately, many of the issues get buried under a mystery plot that distracts us from what I think is the real reason for this film. The mystery involves a body that Pilager hooks with a fishing lure while filming a campaign ad. Are dirty tricks involved? Investigator Danny O'Brien is hired to let a few people know they are suspected. But as a former journalist, he can't help trying to solve the mystery of who this is and how he died. In his searching, he uncovers lots of information that looks bad for people involved with Pilager, but really can't be traced back to any one person.

Click to enlargeThat the film was released a few weeks before the presidential election makes it obvious that Sayles is not a fan of President Bush. He expects people to be able to see Bush in Pilager. His expectation is so obvious that it becomes another distraction from the issues that could have been raised in this film. Silver City is a cynical film. While there are many issues in our electoral system that invite such cynicism, it is just too easy to see the film as being cynical only about President Bush. I am not a Bush supporter, myself, but I would note that many of the issues of campaign marketing and financing are issues that apply to all major candidates. Because Pilager is so obviously a Bush stand-in, the film looks more like an attack on Bush than a film that is asking serious questions about the way we elect our leaders.

This may be one of Sayles' weakest films, which is too bad, because the subject matter is important and needs someone of Sayles' abilities to focus our attention on such issues.
Blog with Darrel Manson
Continue:

OFFICIAL SITE
Publicity information and images © 2004 Newmarket Films. All Rights Reserved.
No other uses are permitted without the prior written consent of owner. Use of the material in violation of the foregoing may result in civil and/or criminal penalties. Credits and dates are subject to change. For more information, please visit their official site.

Hollywood Jesus News Letter
Receive the Hollywood Jesus Newsletter FREE.

Sign up here