|
|
|
THE
OTHERS
There are many spiritual issues
raised in this film. Is belief in Christ something worth dying for?
What happens when you die? Will praying help you to overcome fear?
Review by BETTY HAMM
|

THE OTHERS
(2001)
This page was created on August 10, 2001
This page was last updated on
May 23, 2005
|
|
Directed by Alejandro Amen?bar
Written by Alejandro Amen?bar
Nicole
Kidman .... Grace
Christopher Eccleston .... Charles
Fionnula Flanagan .... Mrs. Mills
Elaine Cassidy .... Lydia
Eric Sykes .... Mr. Tuttle
Alakina Mann .... Anne
James Bentley .... Nicholas
Ren?e Asherson .... Old woman
Michelle Fairley .... Mrs. Marlish
Gordon Reid .... Assistant
Produced
by Fernando Bovaira (producer), Tom Cruise (executive producer),
Jos? Luis Cuerda (producer), Rick Schwartz (executive producer),
Park Sunmin (producer), Paula Wagner (executive producer), Bob Weinstein
(executive producer), Harvey Weinstein (executive producer)
Original music by Alejandro Amen?bar
Cinematography by Javier Aguirresarobe
Rated
PG-13 for thematic elements and frightening moments.
|
|

Trailer
RealVideo low
bandwidth
QuickTime 33
MB 12
MB 6
MB
|

The
Others:
Original Motion Picture Score Alejandro
Amenabar
|
|
Sooner
Or Later They Will Find You.
|
|
SYNOPSIS:
On
the secluded Isle of Jersey in the final days of World War II, a
young woman waits in vain for her beloved husband to return from
the front. Grace (Nicole Kidman) has been raising her two young
children alone in her beautiful, cavernous Victorian mansion, the
one place she believes them to be safe.
But
they are not safe. Not anymore.
When
a new trio of servants arrives to replace the crew that inexplicably
disappeared, startling events begin to unfold. Grace's daughter
reveals she has been seeing and talking with unexplained apparitions
that come and go in every room of the house. At first, Grace refuses
to believe in her children's scary sightings, but soon, she too
begins to sense an intruder is at large.
Who
is there? And what do they want from Grace's family? In order to
find out, Grace must abandon everything in which she believes and
enter the otherworldly heart of the supernatural.
THE
OTHERS is a chilling tale of subtle psychological terror that gets
under the skin and lingers for some time. A brilliantly crafted
supernatural thriller, THE OTHERS begs the question of whom to trust,
what to fear and what to believe, then topples every assumption.
Crafted with a romantic, moody eeriness, the film is the American
debut of young Spanish director Alejandro Amen?bar ("Open Your Eyes")
and also stars Christopher Eccleston. Eric Sykes, Elaine Cassidy
and Fionnula Flanagan co-star as the enigmatic new servants. James
Bentley and Alakina Mann star as Kidman's children?for whom she
will do anything to keep them from harm.
|
Review
by BETTY HAMM
bhamm@efcn.org
Movie Reviewer, Arts Director
Betty is happily married and serves as the Arts Director
at the Evangelical Free Church. She occasionally has a Chic Flic
Night at her home (see Fried Green Tomatoes).
She has an active interest in film.
|
| In
an attempt to create a film similar to the well-written suspense-filled
thrill of ?The Sixth Sense?, Alejandro
Amenabar brings us ?The Others.? I believe it falls well short of
?The Sixth Sense.? Although the mood
was very tense and the plot complicated, it lacked the pull that the
characters of The Sixth Sense gave.
Personally, I never really cared if Nicole Kidman ever figured out
what was going on. Actually, both my husband and I guessed the plot
much sooner than we would have liked. I like being stumped, but this
scripted lacked the mental intrigue I enjoyed. |
|
The
question that always comes to my mind when a ?scary? movie is released
is ?Why do people enjoy them?? I had a woman sitting next to me
during ?The Others.? She announced when she came into the theatre
(which was pretty much sold out by the way) that she hoped people
don?t mind her screams. I asked her if she had seen ?What
Lies Beneath.? She said she had started it, but had to wait
until her husband got home to watch the rest of it. Interesting.
So, at the end of the film I asked her why she goes to scary movies
if she doesn't like them. She responded "Oh no. I love scary
movies." Perhaps in a sense it is our attempt to face our greatest
fears. I mean the reoccurring theme in the scary or horror film
is unleashed, uncontrolled evil and the hero fighting for good or
just plain fighting for his life. Perhaps we feel we will be better
prepared if we watch someone else fail or succeed in this battle.
Perhaps if we laugh at death or evil or hell it becomes less of
a threat or even a non-issue.
|
|
There are many spiritual issues raised in this film. Is belief in
Christ something worth dying for? What happens when you die? Will
praying help you to overcome fear? |
|
The
children are reading through a book on Catholic martyrs. They find
it amusing that two of the martyrs were willing to be beheaded rather
than deny Christ. Their feeling was deny Christ, save your life,
and go on believing in Christ quietly in your heart. However, the
Bible does not treat faith in Christ lightly. Jesus said in Matthew:
"Everyone therefore who shall confess Me before others, I will
also confess that one before My Father who is in heaven. But whoever
shall deny Me before others, I will also deny him before My Father
who is in heaven." When Jesus tells us to ?take up our cross
and follow Him? it is not only a call to discipleship, but also
a call to persecution. When we believe, it is a putting of our entire
trust in the hands of Christ. Either He is worthy of that trust
or He is not. Either He is worthy of following to death or not.
There is no middle ground with Christ.
|
| What
happens when you die? Paul wrote that to be absent from the body was
to be present with Christ. He knew at the time that he would soon
be facing his own death. The political tide was rushing him toward
execution. And yet Paul faced his death encouraging others to follow
Christ. How can someone have such confidence in what was going to
happen to him when he died? The teachings of Christ are interesting
in that you must either believe all that Jesus said or none. Either
He is the son of God or He is a madman. I believe that Jesus is the
Son of God and will argue from that perspective. As the Son of God,
Jesus came from heaven. Therefore He is an authority on what heaven
is like and how we can get there. Jesus tells us that His Father has
a mansion in heaven with many rooms and that He (Jesus) is preparing
a room for us. So believers have a home waiting for them in heaven.
When Jesus was on the cross, He told the thief that professed faith
in Him ?Today you will be with Me in paradise.? So a believer goes
to heaven immediately upon death. The Bible is full of pictures of
both heaven and hell. Both places are portrayed as real not symbolic
places. Heaven is beautiful, filled with God?s glory, believers together
in glorified bodies and able to recognize each other and Jesus. The
streets and gates are described as very exotic, beautiful and richly
decorated. Hell on the other hand is a place separated from God. A
place of no second chances. A place of eternal torment, crying and
horror. A place created for Satan but will also be filled with fallen
angels and those that refuse the gift of life that Jesus offers. |
| Will
praying eliminate fear? The mother tells the son to pray his rosary.
Will going through religious rituals bring Christ closer? When we
read the New Testament, the people that Jesus was the hardest on were
the priests. These were men that had devoted their lives to following
the religious rules. And yet Christ refers to them as whitewashed
tombs - they looked good on the outside but were dead and decaying
on the inside. That is very harsh. Jesus promises us that He will
never leave us or forsake us. Those that have asked Christ for forgiveness
and have asked Him for eternal life enter into an ever-lasting relationship
of faith with Christ. He will be close when we are afraid. He will
give guidance and encouragement and protection. |
|
My faith tells me that Christ is worth risking it all: my life, my
health, my family, my job - everything. Eternity is a very long time.
Life on earth is short and unpredictable. Placing my life in Jesus'
hands today ensures that I will be with Him forever no matter what.
That does not mean that everything is perfect. I will face the same
struggles, fears, troubles and eventually death. The difference is
that I will face them with the knowledge that my God loves me and
will always be with me and that makes all the difference. |
|
I
did not enjoy ?The Others.? There are several reasons for this.
Beyond this point will be spoiler information,
because I do not know how to address the issues without giving away
the plot.
1.
I have no trouble watching a film that I will totally disagree with
spiritually. For example, I really enjoyed ?What
Dreams May Come? even though I believe it portrayed a totally
erroneous view of life after death. However, when a movie portrays
life after death, or a battle between good and evil or the spirit
world and they go out of their way to belittle Judeo/Christian beliefs?
that?s when I have a problem. For example, I did not like Tim Burton?s
?Sleepy Hollow? even though it was
a beautifully filmed movie, it offended my faith. ?The Others? makes
a point of showing a woman of strong Catholic faith in a very poor
light. It shows that her unwavering belief in the Bible and the
teachings of her church as foolish and eventually filled with errors.
Not only is her belief in what happens when you die shown to be
false, her children are shown as much wiser as they make fun of
the church?s teachings.
2.
Some topics in my opinion are so horrific that when they are handled
in an artistic format they should be done so with great wisdom and
care. I am not of the school that believes anything goes in art.
This woman killed her children by smothering them with a pillow.
She went mad in her grief over the loss of her husband, killed her
children and then herself. In the movie?s defense, I think the director
tried to show sympathy for the mother and explain how such a thing
could happen. But I believe it was done poorly. In light of the
similar deaths that have happened in reality, I thought this was
in poor taste.
3.
The ending. No hope. No joy. No future. This family is trapped for
eternity in this house regardless of how they lived, regardless
of their faith. Well that stinks.
|
| ?The
Others? is not a film that will make my recommended list. However,
it does show me through the sold out audiences that people are questioning
life and death. Those of us who know the truth need to be ready to
share it. |
|
PHOTOS
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
include("inserts/comments_bottom_short.htm"); ?>
SCIENTOLOGY
Subject: The Others
Date: Sun, 23 Dec 2001
From: "Greg Estes"
I
found The Others entertaining and interesting however I think the
maker of this film had an agenda. It's no coincidence that it was
produced by Tom Cruise, a known supporter of Scientology, with his
wife (at the time) Nicole Kidman, also of Scientology faith, in
a leading role.
After
watching the movie I felt that a religion had been introduced to
me and not being an expert on Scientology, I looked up information
on it and found some interesting themes that were in the movie such
as reincarnation and an over all theme that we are God of our lives.
The movie made not so subtle criticisms of the Catholic faith while
promoting Scientology to the point that it was almost an advertisement
to visit your local church of Scientology. I encourage viewers of
this movie to read about that religion and you will see it in the
work of Tom Cruise.
As
I said, I enjoyed the movie and in no way am I saying don't see
it, but just pointing out that you may want to think about what
you are seeing and why. It helped open my eyes to this growing religion
and how to recognize those themes in movies. By the way, I am not
a Scientologist nor Catholic.
Greg
Response:
Thanks for your input. There is nothing in the film that promotes
Scientology at all. The film is not about reincarnation, nor any
other doctrine of Scientology. The film is about crsis of faith
and coming to terms with experiences that run counter to our belief
system. -David
SOME
THOUGHTS
Subject: The_Others
Date: Thu, 13 Sep 2001
From: AL
I
ENJOYED BETTY HAMM'S THOUGHTFUL ANALYSIS OF "THE OTHERS". I DID
TAKE ISSUE WITH SOME OF HER INSIGHTS, BUT OVERALL I GAVE THE MOVIE
A GRADE OF "B".
I
ENJOY HORROR MOVIES FOR MANY OF THE REASONS CITED IN THE REVIEW.
MOST HORROR MOVIES TURN INTO GORE-FESTS VERY QUICKLY AND HAVE LITTLE
DEPTH BESIDES SHOCK VALUE. "THE SIXTH SENSE" WAS A RECENT EXAMPLE
THAT WAS NOT GORY, BUT INTELLIGENT AND THOUGHTFUL. COMPARING RECENT
MOVIES WITH "THE SIXTH SENSE" IS LIKE
COMPARING A VAN GOGH PAINTING WITH A FIRST GRADER'S CRAYON DRAWING.
I
ALSO ENJOY SEEING OTHER PEOPLE'S VISION OF THE SPIRITUAL DIMENSIONS.
THE BIBLE HAS SOME GRAPHIC DESCRIPTIONS ABOUT THE SPIRITUAL WORLD:
IN II KINGS 6 ELISHA PRAYS FOR HIS SERVANTS TO SEE THE FIERY HORSES
AND CHARIOTS THAT ARE SURROUNDING THE VALLEY AND ARE READY TO BATTLE
THE KING OF ARAM. IN DANIEL 10, AN ANGEL APPEARS TO DANIEL BEFORE
HIS APOCALYPTIC VISIONS AND TELLS HIM THE KINGS OF PERSIA HAD OCCUPIED
HIM FOR 21 DAYS AND NEEDED ONE OF THE CHIEF PRINCES TO COME BAIL
HIM OUT. WOW! HOLLYWOOD CAN'T EVEN TOUCH STORIES LIKE THESE! WHAT
ARE THESE FIERY HORSES AND CHARIOTS? HOW DO THE PRINCIPALITIES AND
POWERS ENGAGE AND OCCUPY THESE SPIRITUAL BEINGS? HOW DOES THE SPIRIT
WORLD OPERATE? IF YOU ARE PRESENT WITH CHRIST AFTER DEATH AND CHRIST
IS PRESENT WITH THOSE WHO ARE ALIVE, DOES THE SPIRIT WORLD OPERATE
ON A LEVEL THAT THOSE OF US WHO ARE ALIVE ARE COGNIZANT OF?
I
DID AGREE WITH BETTY HAMM'S ANALYSIS OF THE ENDING OF THE MOVIE.
NO HOPE, NO JOY AND A FUTURE STUCK ON A BRITISH ISLAND FOR ETERNITY.
IT WAS A STINKER. I WAS NOT FAMILIAR ENOUGH WITH CATHOLIC THEOLOGY
TO FULLY UNDERSTAND THE ENDING. WERE THEY IN SOME KIND OF HALF-WAY
HOUSE TO HEAVEN OR HELL? OR SOME OTHER POINT WHERE THEY COULD WORK
THEIR WAY TO HEAVEN?
THE
OTHERS
Subject: the others
Date: Sat, 25 Aug 2001
From: heidi
Nicole
Kidman did a great job in this show. The little girl who played
in the show was good too- she seemed like such a little prankster!-
One of my favorite movies of all time was far and away- but she
did a movie a long time ago (I can't remember the name) where her
husband was dying of cancer and she was awful. I was hoping that
she would do well in this movie and that it wouldn't be anything
like that movie. She really does well in movies where strong women
are. I think so anyway. She really did a wonderful job in this movie,
and what an ending!!! It has always seemed to me that the line between
the living and the dead is a very thin line, and this show seemed
to portray that.You never even see the end coming- It reminds me
of the sixth sense, in the way it
ended anyway.good show!
heidi
|
OFFICIAL
SITE
The Others ? 2001 Dimension Films. All Rights
Reserved.
|
|
| |
|
|