When
Scott Rudin purchased the screen
rights to Michael Cunningham's novel, many wondered how easily a film
could be made of such a nuanced, non-linear literary work. Yet the
idea of multiple, interweaving story lines in disparate historical
time-frames is a highly cinematic concept going back at least as far
as 1916 in D.W. Griffith's "Intolerance." With the addition of a top-flight
cast and director, and a screenplay by one of the most acclaimed contemporary
dramatists, The Hours has made an assured, enhanced transition from
page to screen. Director Stephen Daldry says: "I actually found that
the idea of three stories and three women, and the relationship among
them, was a wonderful opportunity to try to create a single narrative."
Screenwriter
David Hare saw Michael Cunningham's
novel as an "extraordinarily accomplished piece of literature."
He adds: "I thought that the tactic of telling three stories without
the reader being able to understand the way they connected was completely
fascinating. Somehow, Michael managed to sustain your interest even
though you didn't know exactly how the pieces fit. And the fascination
of that he accomplished beautifully. Then, when you did understand
how they fit, it became profoundly satisfying."
Hare
understood the screenplay would have to be a different structure
from the one in the novel. "I found my own way of mixing the stories
up and making new connections," he says. "I knew we could replicate
the pleasure the book gives--that of slowly understanding the way
in which the three stories fit together."
But
because nearly everything in the book is what goes on inside the
characters' heads, the biggest challenge for Hare as a screenwriter
was to communicate through action and behavior what was internalized
thought in Cunningham's novel.
"In
film, you can't have inner voice unless you have voiceover," observes
Hare. "We made a very specific decision at the very beginning not
to have voiceover, and once that was decided, I had to invent a
certain number of events which expressed what was going on inside
the characters' heads without spelling it out. For instance, the
whole theme of the way in which Laura's husband has come back from
the war--we need to know how his experience of the war has marked
their marriage. There is the sense of World War II seeping into
the film, which I've had to make explicit in that birthday-party
scene at the end of the film where he talks about how he first saw
her. In the book, of course, that's not expressed outwardly. I had
to invent a whole series of events like that in order to express
what went on inside the characters. For instance, I also quite radically
changed Clarissa's partner and her private life in order to try
and express various things which went on inside their heads."
It
was a challenge Hare enjoyed. "This is where filmmaking becomes
fun. Because not only was I denying myself voiceover; I was extremely
keen to deny myself flashbacks. Obviously, in the book, there's
a great deal about what happens to Clarissa and Richard as young
people, and that informs the book in a wonderful way. But we already
had three stories, and the idea of flashing back within one of those
stories seemed to me a bad one. I wanted to do it through the things
the characters said, and the way they were together, rather than
by showing it. I think that by denying yourself those routes out,
you put a discipline on things which is much richer."
Hare
met with Michael Cunningham
before beginning his work.
"Michael
had originally planned a far longer book, so he was able to give
me invaluable background on all the characters and their lives,"
remembers Hare. "He knew everything about them. He was very generous
with his time and his goodwill. My admiration for what Michael wrote
only grew the more I worked on the screenplay. I think it's very
unusual to write a film of a novel and admire the novel just as
much at the end as you did at the beginning. That was true of Michael's
book. It withstood the scrutiny of film writing brilliantly. What
we're talking about here is a tradition of writers handing on subject
matter, one to another. A woman's life, in a day, is the arc of
her whole life: that's the idea. Michael told me: 'Virginia Woolf
took it one way; I took it another way; now you, David, run with
the ball and go off wherever you want.' And that was a very generous
offer. It was an offer of trust. And of course, if one author makes
that offer to another, you tend to do your best to respect it."
Hare
had already had a long association with Stephen
Daldry before "The Hours." Daldry directed him in his
acting debut in Hare's theater piece, "Via Dolorosa," which played
at the Royal Court in London and ran for four months on Broadway.
"He is a director who has a great gift for understanding the emotional
heart of any material," says Hare.
Daldry
had not yet read Michael Cunningham's novel when Scott Rudin presented
him with an early draft of Hare's screenplay. "I was on holiday
in the south of France when I received the script," he says. "My
first response was that this was a fantastically well-achieved screenplay,
and a wonderful opportunity to try to explore and investigate Mrs.
Dalloway, one of the greatest books ever written."
Daldry
adds that he enjoyed Cunningham's book enormously, and that even
though the author gave the filmmakers free rein to transform the
novel into a film, they remained true to Cunningham's work. "Michael
told us that we should feel free to do whatever we felt was appropriate,"
says Daldry. "It was a very liberating, and as the script developed,
we ended up remaining quite faithful to the rich world explored
in the novel."
For
Daldry, the essence of The Hours is its profound respect for women
and the challenges they faced throughout the turbulent, utterly
unpredictable developments of the twentieth century. "In the film,
our women struggle through the day that they're given, a day they
define for themselves and that others have defined for them," explains
Daldry. "There is a real heroism, and I think that's one of the
things that originally drew me to the script--it's a day in the
life of these three women. And maybe that's every day. Maybe the
journey, and the struggle, and the stoicism and the emotional difficulties
they are facing--maybe the battles and heroics are as much in the
backyard and in the bedroom, as much when you're baking a cake in
the kitchen as they are climbing mountains or winning wars. I think
that often the heroics in women's lives are underestimated, or put
into the background by the heroics in the lives of men. Obviously,
the struggles are enormous and profound; just as important, if not
more so."
Meryl
Streep, who plays Clarissa Vaughan, had originally received
Cunningham's The Hours as a gift from a friend. "I thought the book
was beautiful," she says. "When my agent called me about the film
I couldn't imagine how they were going to make it into a movie,
how so much of an interior world could be translated into a film.
But when the script came to me, I thought it was really wonderful.
David Hare has such a compassionate nature, and he's a consummate
wordsmith."
Streep
was familiar with Hare's extraordinary ability to explore people's
inner thoughts, having appeared in the film version of his play,
"Plenty." "David is able to express things that are inside people,"
says Streep. "He puts them in the situation and makes it actable.
And I think that was what convinced me that 'The Hours' would be
an interesting project to work on."
"What
David Hare managed to do," says Julianne
Moore, who plays Laura Brown, "was to translate both
the emotional reality and the structural reality of the novel. I
honestly didn't think it could be done, but he did it beautifully."
A fan
of Cunningham's novel, Moore adds: "I'm a big reader of fiction,
and I'm very rarely surprised by it. When you read a lot of literature,
you learn to look for clues, and you see what's coming. But The
Hours completely stunned me. I was really surprised by it, and so
thrilled. When someone manages to do that, you feel like you're
twelve again. Michael Cunningham is able to be so incredibly truthful
about the things that are painful and difficult in the human condition,
yet he's tremendously hopeful and inspiring, too. His concept of
getting through 'the hours' of our day and of our lives, and what
that means--that is what is both painful and valuable about life,
all at once. I was so moved by it."
Moore
sees her character as having much in common with Virginia Woolf.
"What Laura shares with Virginia Woolf is her depression. But whereas
Virginia Woolf is aware of it as an illness, something she struggles
with, I think Laura is almost underwater. She's not a person who's
even present in her life. Her deep unhappiness is the state of her
life. What I love about both the novel and the movie is that this
is just another day, another morass of a day, another set of hours
she has to get through. What she doesn't expect is to have a cataclysmic
event in it. It shouldn't be a day that leads to any other, but
it is actually her penultimate day in this particular life. If Laura
defines herself in any way, she's a passionate reader. That's something
that I used for myself. She shares that sense of literary-ness with
Virginia Woolf."
For
Moore, who has two young children, the role of Laura had enormous
resonance. "When I made the movie, my son was three-and-a-half,
and during the shoot I was pregnant with my daughter. In the book,
the little boy is actually younger, but it would have been impossible
to work with a three-year-old on film. I understand what the connection
is between a child and his mother. The fact that this boy was so
connected to his mother, and could feel her depression, and was
so lost--this was absolutely heart-wrenching to me. I'm not certain
I would have understood this had I not been a mother myself. But
what's agonizing is that you realize Laura makes the only choice
she can at the end of her story. In effect, she's choosing to live
rather than die. This is a woman who is confused by issues in a
marriage she doesn't want to be in; she doesn't have any idea about
her sexuality; she's desperately unhappy; she doesn't even know
whether she wants to be in this life--she's a reader, not a participator.
And she's just lost. She has no options. Nothing. It's a different
world, and you see a different world in Clarissa's life. Here's
a woman who had a child because she wanted a child; is with the
lover she wants to be with; has made choices about her life. Laura
has made almost no choices; she's retreated into books."
In
preparation for her role as Virginia Woolf in "The Hours," Nicole
Kidman immersed herself in researching Woolf's life and
work. "Part of playing someone who really existed is finding her
essence," says Kidman. "David Hare gave me a lot of insight into
her, and of course, Michael Cunningham did, too. Through this period,
I just fell in love with her. She was a woman who grappled with
death and madness and love. The profundity with which she managed
to capture the pathos of life has always been incredibly interesting
for me. Yet there was a mischievousness, a playfulness and joie
de vivre in her that made people want to be in her orbit. They were
fascinated by her, attracted to her. And she felt such gratitude
to her husband Leonard for being so tolerant of her. So much of
what she was fighting for was just being able to breathe, being
able to live in London if she wanted to live in London, and not
be trapped, as she saw it, out in Richmond. I think that your creativity
stems from your environment a lot of the time. That really resonated
with me."
The
character of Virginia had a particularly profound effect on Kidman.
"It's very interesting," she says, "how characters come to you at
a certain time in your life when you need them. I don't think I
was in my most fun-loving frame of mind at that time, and she was
cathartic for me in a strange way. There is a beautiful line in
the script about how the dead give us gifts. And for me, Virginia
gave me a gift. That's what's quite strange about the whole experience:
At that time in my life, I needed her. I needed to play her."
To
many, Nicole Kidman might seem an odd choice to play Woolf, especially
due to the lack of a strong physical resemblance. "There's not a
lot of natural physical similarity between Nicole Kidman and Virginia
Woolf," Daldry admits. "But there is a similar kind of animal magnetism.
And I use the word 'animal' in the best sense--in other words, a
danger, an alertness. People describe Virginia Woolf as having been
birdlike. But there is a danger to Nicole and, from what one reads,
a danger to Virginia Woolf. They're both thoroughbreds. Since Nicole
cannot look exactly like Virginia Woolf, we tried to somehow give
an essence of what that extraordinary face was."
Kidman
herself had some trepidation about taking on the part. "You know,
when you have to distort your face the way I did, and when you are
playing something that is so different from you--particularly as
an Australian playing a character that is iconic for Britain and
iconic for feminists--you think, Oh, this is frightening! I really
had to trust the person who was leading me through it. And Stephen
led me through it. He really helped mold and direct me, and gave
me an enormous amount of confidence to move forward with it."
"I
was blessed with my actors," says Stephen Daldry. "Not just Julianne,
Meryl and Nicole but also a supporting cast of extraordinary ability
and extraordinary talent. It was a joy and an education each day
watching their very different methods of working."
Indeed,
"The Hours" was a magnet for actors, and even the smaller supporting
roles attracted major talent.
"I
thought I would never be allowed to do it," says Allison
Janney, who plays Clarissa's lover Sally. "I thought
they could never let me out of filming "The West Wing" long enough.
But they were just as excited about it as I was, and they worked
like crazy to enable me to be a part of it. So I was thrilled."
Janney was also delighted to be playing opposite Meryl Streep. "We
were doing a scene where she was on camera and I was in bed with
her and I have my back to her, and I just went, 'I'm in bed with
Meryl Streep!' It was truly a wonderful moment."
Toni
Collette, who plays Kitty opposite Julianne Moore's Laura
Brown, was equally delighted to be part of the remarkable ensemble
cast. She describes her character as "the bubbly, made-up face of
suppression, always saying one thing and meaning another. Kitty
has lived in a tower her entire life, and now it's her turn to fall.
But she will do it with a smile on her face.
"The
Hours is a brilliant book and the film adaptation is exquisite,"
adds Collette. "While working on the film I had the feeling that
I was very lucky to be even a crumb to this very special cake. It's
such an intelligent, inspirational and emotional piece, I am proud
to be a part of it."
When John C. Reilly was offered
the role of Dan Brown, he didn't have to deliberate long. "It was
pretty much of a no-brainer for me," he says. In addition to the
quality of the project and its cast, Reilly was intrigued by the
possibility of building upon a character that was similar to one
he'd already played in another film. "My first impression when I
read the script was that I'd played this character in a previous
incarnation. I felt like I already knew this guy somehow. He's a
war veteran who was in World War II in the South Pacific, and I
was in "The Thin Red Line," playing a guy who goes through Guadalcanal
in the South Pacific. Somehow I felt like I could relate to his
experience."
Jeff
Daniels, who plays the role of Louis Waters, the former
lover of Richard, the poet who is dying of AIDS, was also intrigued
by his character.
"What
I liked about the part was bringing to life that universal situation
in which two people, revisiting old times after many years apart,
find their way back through the good, the bad and, most importantly,
all those things left unresolved. For better or for worse, here
we are again, as if it were yesterday. It doesn't take long for
the small talk to be replaced with some rather pointed comments,
then the missiles are launched and everybody's ducking for cover.
What are old friends for?"
Daniels
was especially delighted to be in the company of his collaborators.
"It was like being asked to play in the All-Star Game. Go down the
list. It's loaded. Then, throw in Stephen
Daldry, David Hare, Ann Roth [costume designer] -- forget
it. For me, however, the highlight was working with Meryl.
"Also,
Stephen is from the theater, as are most of the cast, so the attention
paid to exploring the character was very specific. Stephen's a great
collaborator. He would go over each and every moment, making sure
we had thought of everything. Sometimes, one choice would lead to
another idea and we'd try that. It was exciting to work with him."
Tony
Award winner Stephen Dillane,
who appears in "The Hours" as Virginia's husband Leonard Woolf,
found the key to his role in David Hare's screenplay.
"I
thought the screen adaptation was excellent, very moving. Leonard
Woolf was a remarkable man in his own right, deeply committed to
his ideals both in his personal life and politically. His autobiography
is a good read. Woolf has the unusual ability to capture contemporary
details that give us insight into the times in which he lived. He
was unusually engaged in the political and aesthetic debates of
his period. He was also a man who tried to live according to his
beliefs, and he records with disarming sincerity and honesty his
successes and failures in this endeavor.
"Some
people think Leonard Woolf was insensitive and overprotective, and
that he obsessively controlled Virginia Woolf's life. Some say Virginia
Woolf both needed and wanted Leonard Woolf's protection from her
own self-destructive instincts. Who knows? The screenplay follows
the book by inclining towards the former interpretation."
Two-time
Academy Awardâ nominee Miranda Richardson,
who portrays Virginia Woolf's sister Vanessa Bell, says that one
of the reasons she was attracted to the "The Hours" was the strength
of David Hare's writing and the idea that her character brings a
certain lightness to Virginia Woolf's life and to the film as well.
"It's
such a beautifully complex script, which reflects the book and yet
has qualities all its own," observes Richardson. "I quite enjoyed
that my character Vanessa, by comparison to her sister Virginia,
has an almost carefree quality about her. The push and pull between
them reminded me of so many sister relationships. They were practically
symbiotic, with a subtle undercurrent of rivalry. I think that Vanessa
felt she had to look after Virginia as she would one of her children,
and yet she also seemed to have the temptation to duck away emotionally
from Virginia's intensity."
During
pre-production, Daldry insisted on a lengthy rehearsal period for
himself and the actors, something that is rare in feature filmmaking.
"Since I come from the theater," he explains, "it's very hard for
me to predetermine my view of a scene, or of a sequence of scenes,
without an exploration with the actors beforehand. For me, it's
the only way to work out the internal dynamics and the emotion of
a scene. From that, I can plan where the camera might or might not
be. There's a great joy in having the writer at rehearsals; he can
rewrite to the input of the actors, and to their strengths and weaknesses.
Most importantly, what we were lucky to have was a wonderfully experienced
group of actors, many of whom have worked extensively in the theater
and are used to this way of working. They were able to participate
in the rehearsal process in a way that David and I could understand.
We found it incredibly useful."
"Stephen is very attentive to the actors and the acting process,"
says Claire Danes, who plays
Clarissa's daughter, Julia. "I have a modest role in "The Hours"
and I rehearsed it more than I have for some leading roles I have
played in other films. Stephen understands what acting is, and takes
real pleasure in helping an actor assemble a character from the
bottom up."
There
was another reason Daldry felt a long rehearsal period was crucial.
"One of the great joys of rehearsing and knowing the screenplay
very well before we shot it was knowing the cutting pattern from
story to story. So rhythmically, what you see is basically what
we rehearsed -- which is unusual. We pretty much knew where one
story was going to lead into another story, and what the collective
rhythm of the stories was, before we shot. In other words, that
was not created in the edit room. We were always able to clue the
actors in to where we were going next."
To
create the look of "The Hours," Stephen
Daldry had the help of production designer Maria
Djurkovic, costume designer Ann
Roth and director of photography Seamus
McGarvey. All worked together to create a visual scheme
that would unify the three stories and emphasize the qualities they
shared.
Roth
concentrated on the look that was found in the Bloomsbury group.
"That whole crowd," she says, "the Bloomsbury crowd -- the painters,
Vanessa and Duncan Grant--their
colors were so strong. They were a rusty color -- a green and a
gray-blue. I wanted to tie all of it -- the whole movie -- all together
with those colors. Julianne Moore wears the same colors as Meryl,
who wears the same colors as Nicole Kidman."
Nicole Kidman singles out Ann Roth's costume for her as a key that
helped her shape the character of Virginia. The shoes, the fabric
of the dress, even a handkerchief --all immediately allowed Kidman
to react in a way that was true to the period and, perhaps, to Virginia
Woolf as well. "As soon as I put that outfit on," says Kidman, "it
was like I was able to move in a different way."
"This
was like designing three separate units," says Maria
Djurkovic, "but making sure that they're all under the
same umbrella, so that the film works as a single entity. For a
production designer, it's a fabulous job. It's almost like putting
a collage together, and you're contemplating what colors to put
in, what colors to leave out. Ann's costumes and Seamus' lighting
helped complete that, so that we have a unified whole."
However,
Daldry knew that to strive for total unity among the stories would
be a mistake. "We knew we always wanted a specific process to unify
the stories, so that there would be not only a coherence in look,
but also a difference. There is a visual opposition that works from
story to story. And a lot of that is in simple things like color.
There is a different palette from story to story, but somehow the
palettes in each one refer directly back from one to another. So
the unifying elements are found in the editing pattern, the color
palette, the camera movements from story to story, and the film-processing
techniques. We tried to avoid what I would describe as 'decorative'
camera movements. Rather than predetermine an emotional response
from a camera movement, we tried to allow the actors to control
the emotional response. We let the camera respect the actors. And
of course, we had a fantastic cast, so the actors do an awful lot
of the work."
Composer
Philip Glass, whose work often
seems to distill the very essence of passing time, has provided
"The Hours" with a tightly-woven musical fabric. "I used the music
to bridge the stories rather than separate them," he explains. "One
of the most interesting things about the movie is that it moves
from story to story and it's common for a theme to start in one
story and to move to the next two. One might have thought each story
should have its own music. I decided not to do that."
Instead,
Glass chose to echo the style in which Michael Cunningham wrote
the novel and in which David Hare subsequently wrote the screenplay
-- using patterns upon patterns, building a continuum that moves
through time and space as the stories meld together.
"I
made a key decision early on that each musical cue would bridge
all three stories," says Glass, "and that turned out to be a very
persuasive way of presenting the score. After all, they really aren't
separate stories at all--each segment is really telling part of
the same story. And the emotional point-of-view remains very coherent,
as all three have to deal with self-annihilation, with survival,
with facing themselves. I was looking for the same sort of coherence
in the music, for it to be a thread that weaves its way through
all three periods in time, a way to bind them into one."
Structural
coherence was the big issue for everyone on the film, remembers
Glass. "Michael Cunningham grappled with it in his novel, Stephen
Daldry had to deal with it as a director, and it was essential to
the music. It's a very interesting idea that the imagination of
a writer can reach that far into different times and different lives
and find the connections -- it makes a powerful statement about
the power of art."
Filming
began in February 2001 in New York, with two weeks of work that
was mostly confined to the modern sequence in Greenwich Village.
The exterior of Clarissa's apartment was on an historic block of
West 10th Street, next to a house where Mark Twain had once lived.
Richard's apartment was located across town in the Meat Market district.
Following
the New York location filming, the crew moved to the Miami area
to shoot exteriors for the Laura Brown sequence, which is meant
to take place in Los Angeles in the 1950s. "We looked for a specific
sort of '50s tract housing in L.A.," says Daldry, "but there were
better period residential areas in Florida, and they were perfectly
maintained. A lot more modernizing has been done in L.A."
Laura's
street was in the Miami suburb of Hollywood. Many of the facades
of the bungalows and one-story homes on the block were repainted
in pastel 1950s shades, and cars of the period were also added.
When Laura goes to a huge old hotel for the afternoon to escape
her home life, it's the historic 1920s Biltmore in Coral Gables.
One of the grandest and most venerable luxury resorts of the South,
the Biltmore was receiving former president Bill Clinton on the
same day the crew filmed there, and the hotel was crawling with
Secret Service agents.
Production
moved next to London, where many interiors were filmed on the stages
of Pinewood Studios. For the home of Virginia and Leonard Woolf
in Richmond, an old house just south of the suburb of Luton was
found. (Richmond now lies directly in the flight path of Heathrow
Airport, and the noise factor prohibited filming there.) Daldry
had hoped to use Monks House in Sussex, where Virginia spent her
final days, as a location, but it had been turned into a museum,
and is also compromised now by restricted views.
"We
looked for other houses in Sussex," he explains, "and the location
manager came each day to my house in Hartfordshire with all the
pictures. Finally she said, 'What's extraordinary is that this house
looks like the houses in Sussex.' We talked it through, and realized
my house would be the best location. And I loved filming there.
It was glorious. The crew was very respectful of my house. Normally,
I wouldn't let a film crew anywhere near it! Quite coincidentally,
we had filmed Richard's apartment in New York City in a building
where I also live, in the Meat Market district."
In
the early spring, Nicole Kidman had to film her suicide sequence.
"She was aware," says Daldry, "that we would have to put her in
a real river with a fast current, and she was going to have to get
underwater and stay underwater. It was a seriously dangerous situation.
But as far as Nicole was concerned, there was never any question
that anybody else would do it. That sequence took several days to
film, including the part where Virginia's body has to be dragged
along by the current on the bed of the river. When you see those
shots in the film, that is Nicole Kidman."
Kidman,
and the other actors, made it a point to come back in for even the
smallest of insert shots. "At one point," explains Daldry, "I wanted
some close-up inserts of Virginia's hand while it was writing. It
seemed illogical to get anybody else to do those shots. Nicole was
busy doing another film, but she came back in to London, got into
costume, and we filmed her handwriting. That kind of professionalism
and care from the actors was fantastic. They made huge efforts to
come back in on the film after principal photography for small shots
like that whenever we needed them." Kidman, who is left-handed,
learned to write with her right hand for her part, and even managed
to imitate Woolf's distinctive script.
"The
whole shoot was a good experience," says Ed
Harris, who plays Richard, Clarissa's friend and former
lover. "The set was run very, very well, with a lot of respect.
It wasn't a lot of people fooling around. There was a certain demeanor
which I appreciated a lot, because it was fairly intense stuff that
we were working on."
"Everyone
was very focused on the work they were doing," Daldry agrees. "But
it was fun, because the work was really serious. And that's what
made it fun--serious fun. This was a fantastically collaborative
process between all the participants. The level of collective creative
investment was remarkable. All the way through, it felt like a serious
team effort. And what a team to have!"
With
a finished film rooted in a literary source that may be unfamiliar
to many, is Daldry now concerned about "The Hours" being accessible
to general audiences?
"I
would hope," he says, "that if you knew nothing about Mrs. Dalloway,
if you knew nothing about Virginia Woolf, that it would not make
one iota of difference in your enjoyment and appreciation of this
film. But people who have read Mrs. Dalloway know that it's a treasure
map, and they will, I hope, find as much joy as we did in the exploration."
|