|
include("inserts/comments_bottom_short.htm"); ?>
LIKE
MOST THINGS, IT'S WHAT YOU MAKE OF IT
Subject: Dungeons and Dragons
Date: Fri, 27 Jul 2001 17:22:32 -0400
From: Steve
David-
I read your tragic-sounding final statement in your movie report
about dreading being raked over the coals about not throwing rocks
at D&D. I have not seen the movie, but I wanted to give you some
hope and commisseration.
I
have designed and led D&D gaming sessions now about monthly for
almost 20 years. My wife and I get together to play with three other
Christian couples who have a shared artistic/dramatic bent and have
a marvellous time. We have found that the so-called "geeky teenager"
game unravels much more richly as adults. The game's genre is uniquely
about cooperating together on common goals, solving puzzles, coming
to eachother's rescues, role-playing outrageous or real-life scenarios,
and thinking on our feet in a way that few other games allow. Coming
together for game playing is not an unusual pastime for Christians;
but in how many games do you all work together as a team for the
benefit of everyone, where teamwork, creative problem solving, collaboration,
and innovation is rewarded? It is the antithesis of the Survivor/Weakest
Link phenomenon, and actually allows for some of the "one-anothering"
admonishions in the New Testament to happen during a game. Everybody
wins or loses together.
The
makers of the game have indeed set up a mythos of deities loosely
based upon pagan myths and ancient stories. Magic exists, and your
character may be of a type that can cast spells. For us, in no way
has this ever smacked of the occult or made any of us even the slightest
bit interested in it. Players don't cast spells, the characters
do. It's not real, or even acted out. We have easily minimized this
aspect of the game... but it is after all FANTASY in the Tolkien
/ C.S. Lewis / King Arthur / Lloyd Alexander / Renaissance Fair
/ Sleeping Beauty vein.
I
suppose there is a way kids could get to the occult from the game,
but is it really in any more a directed fashion than video games,
books, movies, or other avenues? I suppose it can be abused like
many other things - but I feel it has an overly bad reputation among
Christians, and I have encountered that. When the game was on its
rise in popularity in the early 80's, my denomination's weekly magazine
investigated, dissected, and playtested the game and rendered it
harmless but suggested adult supervision and guidance. There are
some people for which any type of role-playing is probably not recommended.
I
wonder what is really more damaging to relationships and fellowship...
cooperating together and brainstorming solutions and doing creative
puzzles while playing a game like D&D or playing Monopoly where
the object is to get rich while bilking your so-called friends.
More Monopoly games seem to end in fights, hurt feelings, and trash-talking
than not. In this way, we have found that D&D is a wonderful party
game where everyone works together and has a good time.
The
game has its potential problems, but that is only if you cannot
distiguish form from content.
Steve
DON'T
UNDERSTAND
Date: Fri, 5 Jan 2001
From: Twinky
Hey
David. I love your website, I'm on here almost daily. Just can't
get enough of Hollywood Jesus! I've never seen the Dungeons and
Dragons movie... but I know a couple people that have "played" the
game or whatever it is... and I really don't understand. Christians
that have played it are very hesitant to admit that they have, and
say it's Satanic or dealing with witchcraft. One of my friends said
that her friend played it and is now Wiccian because of it... I
thought it was just a role-playing game. I really know nothing about
it, so I was hoping that you could help me. If not, do you know
of somewhere (website?) that could? I really would like to know
what's behind this whole fear of Dungeons and Dragons.
Thank you. (please do not post my e-mail address)
Responses:
The Wiccans have not benefited from Dungeons and Dragons. Nor, has
any other religious group. The movie is harmless.
THE
EVANGELICAL TRAP
Subject: Thank You
Date: Fri, 15 Dec 2000
From: "Wes Wilson"
Thank
you for not falling into the evangelical trap of condemning Dungeons
and Dragons on the sparce accusations of few convicted felons and
spiritual schizophrenics. I lived a very religious youth and remember
many fond all-nighters with my friends playing Dungeons and Dragons
in my parent's basement. I have read too many ill-advised spiritual
warnings based on disproven urban legends and am tired of hearing
this elaborate tabletop game equated to a satanic set of training
wheels. Your even-handed approach is a welcome, and your search
for guidence in the mundane is to be applauded. I hear this movie
is trite garbage, but I'll probably go see it for the special effects
alone. Just the name makes me dream of dungeon crawls and political
intrigue. Even as an adult, I yearn to find time to play again...
because is my youth, we wrote our own adventure novels.
Wes Wilson
|