Augustana may take you to Boston, Los Angeles, the midwest and back to California, but their music is unlikely to take you anywhere but to great disappointment. Granted, in a strange way, this is a compliment for their first effort, All the Stars and Boulevards, an album that starts out with great promise, but ends in a formula that becomes noticeable early in their writing.
Their writing is predictable, with the chorus building, the verses being more laid back, finally building into a bridge that soars higher than the verse or chorus. It is the same formula that many bands have used to bring much commercial success (see Coldplay, Creed, and Nickleback). Unfortunately, as a lover of music, it leaves me bored, which is so disappointing because tracks like "Mayfield," "Bullets," and "Boston" are good songs, a great start to what I believe is a promising career for Augustana.
However, after Boston, things take a drastic turn for the worse, where it seems that the same thing is being sung over and over and over...and over again. Dan Layus apparently is focused on failed relationships which have turned him to loneliness and alcohol. And artistically speaking, this is not necessarily a bad thing, because for many artists, these moments lead to soul searching, to asking the basic questions of life, to finding meaning or finding none. It is these situations when art transcends into being able to speak into people's lives in a profound way, something Augustana is simply unable to do.
So, what is my recommendation for Augustana? It is hard to say. Because I am glad I picked up their album, because their potential is limitless. However, this is just another pop/rock album that will make them money but is really nothing artistic. Having said that, this is not a bad album to pick up, but do not expect too much.
Here is a run down of the tracks:
"Mayfield": A great start to the album, a track that deals with growing up, and dealing with a failed relationship wondering..."Are we gonna make it?" A song that I am sure they will be playing for years to come. (ITunes Rating: 3 stars)
"Bullets": More proof that Layus can write great songs, even if lyrically the songs are not that deep or lacking. His spacing and voice make Bullets a much better song than what it would have been. (ITunes Rating: 3 stars)
"Hotel Roosevelt": Again, lyrically the song just lacks. Plus, it is now the third song about a relationship, and it is starting to get a little old at this point in time. There is some good music potential here, but the finished product is all I have to go on. (ITunes Rating: 2 stars)
"Boston": No doubt their strongest song on this album, despite the Coldplay'ish style. Finally, the lyrics are going somewhere that could connect people with this song. Lines like "In the light of the sun, is there anyone?" and "You dont' know me/You don't even care/You don't wear my chains" could very well connect with a younger generation that very much feels broken off from any type of true community. Vocally the song soars, and there is a lot of good to take from this song. (ITunes Rating: 4 stars)
"Stars and Boulevards": This is where you begin to wonder when Layus is going to realize that he is writing the song over and over again. He is in some disconnected relationship where he hopes it will work out but probably knows that it will not. (ITunes Ratins: 2 Stars)
"Feel Fine": This is where I began to wonder, "Was 'Boston' really just two tracks ago? If you want to see what this song is about, look at any of other songs I listed. (ITunes Rating: 1 star)
"Wasteland": A very dark song with lines like "Here we're nothin more than fools and whores and sad highs/through the summer sand we're living in the wasteland." Again, the music here is really good stuff, and Layus brings you into the darkness of the world, the darkness of sin. (ITunes Rating: 3 stars)
"Lonely People": At this point I was really tired of the drinking references (like 6 or 7 now). Not just because I think drinking should not be sung about, but because it is a cop out from really thinking through issues, something an artist should do. There is no doubt in my mind that there are many people in this world that drink away their nights, never thinking about anything besides that. However, as an artist, Layus should not fall into that trap with his songwriting, and unfortunately he does. Artists should always seek to ponder the question "Why..." a question Layus has not gotten to yet. (ITunes Rating: 1 star)
"Sunday Best:": More good music, but the formula has been put in place, and because of that, by now the album is not what it could have been. (ITunes Rating: 1 star)
"California Burning": More isolation and having broken from any type of community. Layus writes "and I'm here, wondering where the sun has gone/driving through a midwest storm/asking why there's no one home." Layus sounds like one longing for something real, and if he thinks a little deeper, he could have some good stuff, but he has not yet, which leaves songs like 'California Burning' as more or less having great potential, but not possessing any. (ITunes Rating: 1 star)
"Coffee and Cigarettes": Not much here. (ITunes Rating: 1 star)
Augustana could become something great, the same thing I once thought about Coldplay (and still do). Augustana could move beyond the surface level lyrics into something deep, and if they do, this could be a truly great band some day.