Wednesday, June 23, 2004

Love Me if You Dare

LINKS
—Overview
—Trailers, Photos
—About this Film
—Spiritual Connections


Click to enlargeLove Me if You Dare makes me want to take my analytical skills and chuck them into the nearby trash can. What can one make of this movie? It is a fairy tale, a tragedy, a slice of true life, a great myth: idealistic, depressing, offensive -- and yet invigorating. As far as stimulating the mind, stirring up both opposition and relief, this film is by most standards an excellent film. I must admit, however, that I was somewhat frustrated by my inability to back this story into a corner and pin down writer/director’s Yann Samuell’s message. Nevertheless, all great films do make you think. They make you dream. They make you question what you know to be true. They force you to observe life from a different point of view. Since there is no proper corner for this film, perhaps some observations are in order.

Click to enlargeThis movie “speaks� about love and the reckless passion that often accompanies romantic thrill rides. It makes bold statements about love that, though I do not want them to be true, often are:

Love is selfish and cruel – Sophie and Julien make dares that destroy the other’s life

Love is jealous – Neither will allow the other to love someone else.

Love is a game – Sophie can never tell when Julien is sincere and when he is only playing the game.

Love breaks promises – Sophie is deeply wounded by Julien’s willingness to break his promises.

Love puts you in danger because it gives the other person control – Julien almost kills Sophie without remorse, and likewise Sophie returns the favor.

Love isolates you from family – Julien must deny his father to keep the game going.

Love hurts those around you – The genuine relationships of family, friends, and innocent bystanders are lost as the lovers pursue each other at all costs.

Love makes you hate – Each lover hates the other at different points in the story, usually for injustices done. They also hate themselves for their own willingness to put up with it.

Love helps you defy society without guilt – Sophie and Julien act out against authorities, social tenets, and their commitments to family and work…all in the name of the game of love.

Love is a myth that cannot be lived out – The tragic lovers fail to connect time and time again, only to be unified in death.

Click to enlargeIt seems that the word “love� should not begin these sentences because genuine love has no part in these actions and attitudes. What we often label as “love� is actually a variation of it that has been tainted by our own selfish desires. It starts out innocent and ends in destruction. Without a doubt, all of us can relate to one or more personal experiences in this list, and we are greatly impacted by the association of these pains with the term “love.� We become jaded and give up entirely on the hope of finding true love.

Fortunately, God is not jaded. He continues to love us and to teach us how to love one another. With the ultimate example of Christ’s death on the cross, God demonstrated what Sophie and Julien could not: selfless love. Rather than trying to kill us as punishment for our hateful offenses (i.e., Julien’s stunt on the train tracks), Christ gave his own life so that we could start over and live free from revenge, ruin and self-destruction.

Christ also taught that we are to love one another, earnestly and from the heart. He promoted unity, self-sacrifice, family, community, sincerity, trust, freedom, building one another up, and sincere, selfless love that is not a myth. It can be attained. In my own experience, it cannot be attained without His intervention, because my heart is always veering toward selfishness. But, I am thankful for the times when I am encouraged by friends, the Bible, the radio, sermons, movies, and time alone in prayer . . . God always seems to help change my mind about the way I interact with those in my life that I supposedly “love.� His love transcends my desire for gain, revenge, punishment, and for holding grudges. His love is not a game or a myth, and for that, I am thankful.

Note from Mel: Believe me when I say this movie touches on so many more topics than I have time or space to address. It is worth seeing simply to generate some deep, real, and meaningful conversation. I encourage you to see it and post your comments in the forum. I’ll be checking back periodically to read and respond to your thoughts . . . a very complex film. Go see it!

LINKS
—Overview
—Trailers, Photos
—About this Film
—Spiritual Connections

6 Comments:

Anonymous said...

I absolutely agree with your blog. Your points are strong and you seemed to understand the movie well. I enjoyed it, but I did find the end very depressing. That the only way these two people could be together is through death. I just wanted to comment that I liked and agreed with the way you viewed the film.

1:24 PM  
Anonymous said...

this movie has nothing to do with Christ. Bringing up Christ only shows your ignorance. Love is beyond religion and beyond one man. God is what the individual feels. The relationship between Sophie and Julien makes this a clear point...it's a beautiful ending. it's something ALL people can relate to (if this were a religious movie, could this be said?) anyway, Julien and Sophie live free on earth and in heavenn as they have finally found a way to put aside their grievances..WIHTOUT the help of Christ (they did it ALONE).
beautiful story, beautiful ending!!!

7:55 PM  
Melinda Ledman said...

Thanks for posting, but I'm not sure what you mean about bringing Christ into it. I never said that the movie had anything to do with Christ. In fact, I said exactly the opposite - that the two had opposite views on love.

"Fortunately, God is not jaded. He continues to love us and to teach us how to love one another. With the ultimate example of Christ’s death on the cross, God demonstrated what Sophie and Julien could NOT: selfless love."

My point was that Sophie and Julien couldn't ever express true selfless love, not that Christ somehow helped them do it. I don't think they ever got that far.

I haven't seen the movie in a while, so I'm not sure I can comment in detail. But, tell me, what did you love about the ending? I'm curious because many people didn't like it. You said "they live free on earth and in heaven as they have finally found a way to put aside their grievances." Can you explain that?

Also, please know that I never thought this film INTENDED to be spiritual (or religious as you said) at all. It didn't. Most don't. I viewed it simply as a commentary on love. But, we at HJ, review stories from a spiritual perspective. And about the only spiritual connection I could make was that Christianity and this film's versions of love were very different.

That said, I'd love to hear what you meant by, "God is what the individual feels. The relationship between Sophie and Julien makes this a clear point." You made a different spiritual connection than I did. Let's chat.

8:46 PM  
tine said...

Hi Melinda

My name is Tine, I'm a Belgian language student. I'm working on my graduate school thesis right know and therefore I chose this wonderful movie: Jeux d'enfants. I see you also adored this movie and that you've been doing a lot of thinking about it. I was wondering if you have any idea how I can find the French script. I need it to make Dutch subtitles afterwards. I'm quite short of time because last week I decided to change my thesis subject (the first was disastrous, a grammar study)Unfortunately, I can only find the English version of the script. So I'd be delighted if you or anyone else could help me finding the French version.

Thank you

3:44 AM  
Melinda Ledman said...

Unfortunately, I don't speak French, so it would be a bit of a disaster for me to try to find the script. I would definitely start looking online. However, there are all kinds of scripts available for each movie (shooting scripts, drafts, and final versions), so be sure to check any scripts you find online to make sure the dialogue matches the movie!

Also, many book stores sell scripts, at least here in America. You can check on amazon.com and also whatever the French equivalent would be. Again, check your script version.

Here are a couple of other ideas:

1. You could use a language translator program (usually available online) to translate the English script into French. However, that might be a waste if your job is to translate it into Dutch...the one I like to use is www.freetranslation.com

2. You can contact the director through IMDB.com. They offer a "free trial" for their contact information directory, though I have never actually tried it. Check out this link: http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1367933/contact
The only problem with this route is that they'll probably give you a mailing address. Since time is a problem, that may not work for you.

3. I can ask my French friends. :) I have two or three of them who might know the right resources to use - and at least they can read the language. I'll send out an e-mail today.

You can e-mail me directly at hjmledman@yahoo.com so we can correspond about this.

Thanks for the inquiry - I'll see if I can help!!

10:45 AM  
Melinda Ledman said...

Sorry Tine, no luck with the script. My French friends couldn't find anything online either. Best wishes to you as you pursue this project. Sorry I couldn't be of more help.

P.S. If you use Google to search, it gives a "translation" option to the side of the link. That will help you get at least from French to English, or maybe where you are, into Dutch.

9:30 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home