Thursday, December 08, 2005

The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe

LINKS
— Overview
— Other Reviews

— Cast and Crew
— Photo Pages

See, I told you he was real.� This is the great line that Lucy Pevensie delivers to her two siblings as Father Christmas drives off after leaving them with the gifts that will equip them to fight for Aslan and Narnia. Georgie Henley is a very gifted little actress, but long before she and the others arrived at this scene in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, Andrew Adamson had me. I was enthralled, enchanted, and excited to see Lewis’ work faithfully reproduced (well... mostly) on the giant screen. I was truly moved as I saw my own imagination laid bare before me. I was relieved as I realized with the closing credits that C. S. Lewis himself would probably be able to accept this interpretation of his book—not feeling led to condemn it as another imagination-killer.

Many adults will see this film and many of them will probably even criticize me for being facile and too easily entertained and pleased. My emotional response to the screening of this story will most certainly be disdained by reviewers who will find plenty to criticize, especially in the failed technical aspects and the watered-down violence necessary for the maintaining of a PG rating. I will boldly stand my ground, however, because I believe that Adamson has shown by his interpretation that he understands Lewis’ heart.

The movie version of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe is in no way preachy or blatantly Christian. This actually fits well with Lewis, who though exposed to religion from birth, took a long road through atheism and agnosticism before he became a Christian and made his peace with God. Just as the whole story isn’t confined to one book but flows through seven, this film leaves the door open to further exploration of the spiritual themes common to and expanded upon by the other Narnia stories. Those familiar with the Bible will see the Bible. Those unfamiliar may be led to seek and ask questions just as Lewis did. No one gets beaten over the head or feels like a victim of brainwashing or overzealous evangelism. Not many are comfortable with the yelling street preacher approach, and Lewis himself preferred an appeal to the intellect, whether a child’s or an adult’s.

Some Christians may be led to criticize the movie because it is not an obvious theological treatise on the redemptive work of Jesus Christ who is represented by Aslan in Lewis’ stories. It may be maintained, however, that this would have been in direct opposition to Lewis’ intent anyway. Remember… Lewis undertook the writing of his children’s series after publishing decades of amazing theological works. His intention was to allegorize the story of God and mankind’s spiritual journey toward Him, making the journey inviting to children without interfering with their natural innocence or dictating the product of their imaginations. I have pointed out elsewhere that Lewis believed a book worth reading as a child was also worth reading as an adult (non-fiction excepted) or it wasn’t really worth reading at all. The wise person can see the benefit of a well-written children’s book, as it becomes a generational bridge and a springboard for all kinds of conversation.

Finally, becoming an adult does not preclude the maintenance and use of a good, fertile imagination. Sometimes the exercising of faith takes a great deal of imagination! By definition, “faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see� (Hebrews 11:2). We don’t know all the answers and we don’t understand how everything works. We place our faith in hundreds of things and circumstances every day: the sun will come up in the east, the lights will come on when the switch is thrown, the car will start when we turn the key, the hard drive on our computer will regurgitate what we want it to on command, nothing will happen to our loved ones when they are far away from us.

There is no difference between faith in these things than there is in the child-like enjoyment of a place like Narnia. Adults who can release their childlike qualities have a better chance of overall survival. Not because it is good to be in denial or to master escapism, but because everyone needs a break from this messy world occasionally—the alternative is to go stark raving mad or become so depressed that madness might look like a kinder alternative. The Pevensie children “escape� from London and the harsh reality of a world at war (with real bombs falling all around them) to the countryside where their imaginations can be cleansed and filled with thoughts and images more appropriate than death and destruction. Jesus had a similar strategy to share in Matthew 18:3:

“I tell you the truth, unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven.�
Too much over-analyzing and too many demands for proof kill the ability for faith to work and separate us from the mystery that has been planted deep within us. Too much reality leaves us feeling like life is dull, pointless, and even useless. King Solomon bemoaned it well: “There is nothing new under the sun. All is vanity.� Lewis said that we all need catharsis—release and renewal. I am unashamed to say that my first reaction when the lights came up was to sit frozen in thought. My first words… “I don’t want to go back to the real world!� The feelings of being somehow cleansed lasted for most of the weekend.

Images Copyright 2005 Disney Enterprises, Inc. and Walden Media, LLC. All rights reserved.

Continue:
— Overview
— Other Reviews

— Cast and Crew
— Photo Pages

8 Comments:

A disappointed Christian said...

I have never heard of these books. I would not have seen the movie if my Pastor had not commented on it last Sunday. I went into the theater hoping that this was something we could use in our faith battles with the secular world. Hoping I could shout, "praise the Lord" when it was over.

I found the movie very slow and dull. Though I enjoyed the graphics and Lucy, the rest was a let down. Perhaps I was looking for too much from this film. The biggest problem in the 21st century is that Christianity is becoming folklore, this film didn't help. It may even push us Christians closer to being labled as “Fairy tale followers.� You bring Father Christmas into the same story as our Lord, you may as well bring in the Tooth Fairy and the Easter Bunny. Then when you try to explain that Jesus is real but the rest are not. Why will they want to differentiate them?

Maybe I’m just bummed and in a bad mood. All that money spent, all the talk at church, all those possibilities of conversation about the Lord. Gone. Logged as just another silly fairy tail. I pray the book had better appeal. This movie will not draw anyone closer to the truth.

11:02 PM  
Vanessa said...

I thoroughly enjoyed the movie's underlaying christian tones and the fact that it was present, but not actualized. I am not Christian by any means, but there are elements of Christianity that are necessary to understand in the present.
The fact of the matter is, The Chronicles of Narnia is so much more than a Christian allegory. When we reduce a piece of art to a simple descriptive term, we are ignoring the potential for the movie to effect its audience in more ways. I am saddened by the fact that priests and preachers around the United States have been asking their parishioners to see this movie. By doing so, they are falsely asking their followers to look for their religion to the detrement of many other important aspects of the film. Of course you are disappointed with The Chronicles of Narnia, you went only expecting an allegory of your faith and that what you left with. Unfortunately, you only left with a small portion of this film.

11:53 AM  
Anonymous said...

I am also a non-Christian. I really enjoyed the book when I was a little kid. When I found out years later the book was a Christian allegory, I don't want to say that it soured me to the books, but once I knew that, it was always on my mind. The same with the movie, my mind kept humming away at the hidden meanings while I really tried to not do so and enjoy it on face value. It was a good film. Try to just watch the movie.

2:49 AM  
Naomi said...

I adored the film, but then I adored the books - both as a child and now as an adult. I took my parents (my father is a pastor) and my 6 year old daughter to see it and though the wolves made her afraid (they should!) and Aslans death made her cry (ditto! - I cried too!) we all enjoyed it. 10/10 for CGI, plot, acting and sticking to the original!

3:18 AM  
heather said...

All comments reflect the big problem--what IS reality?? Is is the Christian aspect of the film; is it the beauty of the story; is it the good in all of us wanting to voice "itself"? What is reality? Do you listen to the story of man who just took $20 from someone (stole it)--about how his family is starving? Or do you listen and side with the man who had his $20 stolen? Reality MUST be defined--and it must be defined by someone bigger than you or I so that law will govern us all. As for me, I choose to see law defined by the Creator of the universe and God of the Bible: Yahweh. All you others choose to define reality through your eyes, or the eyes of some "great man." Revelation, truth, and salvation (what will happen to all of mankind) mujst come through God.
"Good point," you Christians might be thinking, but you are the ones who I am most confused by. The world who does not have a true source of truth has thier excuse: ignorance. But what do you have? Unfortunately, ignorance of what God has decreed creates the confusion.
Let us stand on Scriptures first and then compare all to that standard. Lewis was an intellectual giant contributing much to the Reformed Faith but is this book/movie in accord with Scripture? Our reviews should not be about anything other than measuring it to Scripture.

1:54 PM  
lucyandres5501 said...

I read over your blog, and i found it inquisitive, you may find My Blog interesting. My blog is just about my day to day life, as a park ranger. So please Click Here To Read My Blog

11:04 AM  
walteralexander4249525665 said...

I read over your blog, and i found it inquisitive, you may find My Blog interesting. So please Click Here To Read My Blog

http://pennystockinvestment.blogspot.com

7:13 PM  
Bosco said...

Now I really wanna read the other books in the Narnia series. This film is beautiful and so lovely and British... cough. God save the Queen and all that. I have to say the battle scenes really impressed me, like no other battle before. I mean LOTR was pretty impressive, but there is something outstanding about all the different animals and beasts and giants fighting with children leading them. The film is a lot more enclosed than LOTR which speeds the story along. The children did a fine job and a lovely supporting cast. Talking animals rule. Fantastic stuff. 8.5/10

6:30 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home