Friday, December 09, 2005

Episode 10: "Coming Home"



"The story is as old as time itself, the prodigal son returns home..."

Now this is an interesting thought: The story is as old a time itself. As I heard the words of Mary Alice, I thought to myself, "No it's not. It's as old as Jesus. After all, he was the one who told the story." But after some thought, I realized it IS as old as time itself, because it's a parable of the human condition. And really, if the parable was meant to be about the relationship of God and man, then it is most certainly a story that began with the creation of time.

So, here's a summary of the Prodigal Son parable (see full text below): The younger of two sons asks his father for his inheritance. He goes and squanders it on wild living just before a famine sets in. He begins to starve and goes to work feeding pigs (a low and disgraceful job for a Jew). He is so hungry and humiliated that he decides to go home to ask forgiveness and to work for his dad. As he approaches, the father sees him coming down the road. Instead of being angry or taking revenge, the father runs to him, embracing him before the son can even speak. The son apologizes, saying he isn't worthy to be called a son anymore. The father interrupts him before he can ask for a job and restores him to his previous position. He then throws a big party in his honor. The older son catches wind of all this and is very angry. When he confronts his father, the father says, "...We had to celebrate and be glad, because this brother of yours was dead and is alive again; he was lost and is found."

On Wysteria Lane, Zack and Paul are reunited. Though this story line isn't developed much along the prodigal son strain, we know that Mike isn't willing to give up on Zack. Like the father in the parable, Mike will wait.

Susan and her dad try to reconcile their relationship - or at least form one. He resists at first and tries to scare her off. She persists. His wife warns Susan, "He'll break your heart," and she finally lets him go. But in the end, he comes back to Susan and let's her know he's willing to try to have a relationship. In this story line, Susan's dad is the prodigal. His actions line up directly with those of the prodigal son - he wants his own way, he likes his indulgences, he breaks his father's (Susan's) heart, and after he is set free, he thinks twice about the value of the relationship. And she...accepts him back.

The story of Bree and Andrew is a little darker. Andrew is more like the prodigal son because he has malice in his heart. We know that somewhere down the road he will use the information his mother disclosed to destroy her. Since most of us don't come from a Middle Eastern background, we can't comprehend the level of insult implied in the prodigal son's request. It's not equivalent to a modern-day youth asking for his college fund money to go party. The inheritance was only given at DEATH, which means that the son was saying his father as worth as much alive as dead. The focus was on the money, not the relationship. This level of hatred brought severe shame upon his father, and the fact that the father granted his request would have been shocking to the Jewish hearers of the day. The son should have been disowned for his disrespect.

The only thing more appalling to the Jewish folks captivated by Jesus' parable would be the ending to the story. Rather than taking revenge on the hateful son, the father sees his repentant heart and restores him to sonship. Would you be disappointed if Bree reacted to Andrew's malevolence like the father in the parable? Or would you be happy for Andrew if after obliterating Bree's heart, he is restored? The Father understands the value of relationship over the spiteful hatred of a wayward youth and prideful arrogance.

In it's own way, Lynette's storyline mirrors the prodigal son parable because the she fights for her estranged child. Although the baby committed no wrong, they are still separated and Lynette will do anything in her power to reunite that relationship. This kind of desperation is shown in the parable by the father running to his son. Again, we can't appreciate this. What's so dramatic about running? According to Jewish custom at the time, running was completely indignified. To raise up one's clothing, to show one's legs, to run...humiliating. Absolutely humiliating - but the father was more concerned about the relationship.

At the end of the episode, Mary Alice comments something to the effect of "It's all about family." I don't have a transcript yet. But, it is, isn't it? How much more valuable is our relationship with God than our rebellious hearts? How much more important are we to God than all of our mistakes combined? It seems that God understands this concept, but we tend to miss it. We want to say that we aren't good enough to be forgiven. We want to earn our keep, like the prodigal son. We value the temporal blessings God gives over the eternal relationship that fills our souls. How do we miss the messages of this story?

I challenge you to read the text below. It's from the Bible, NIV version. The passage is Luke 15:11-32, the story of the Prodigal Son. Even if you think you know it, reread it with new eyes. Try to find something you missed. Think about your own heart and the heart of God toward you. Here it is...

There was a man who had two sons. The younger one said to his father, "Father, give me my share of the estate." So he divided his property between them. Not long after that, the younger son got together all he had, set off for a distant country and there squandered his wealth in wild living.
After he had spent everything, there was a severe famine in that whole country, and he began to be in need. So he went and hired himself out to a citizen of that country, who sent him to his fields to feed pigs. He longed to fill his stomach with the pods that the pigs were eating, but no one gave him anything. When he came to his senses, he said, "How many of my father's hired men have food to spare, and here I am starving to death! I will set out and go back to my father and say to him: Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you. I am no longer worthy to be called your son; make me like one of your hired men."

So he got up and went to his father. But while he was still a long way off, his father saw him and was filled with compassion for him; he ran to his son, threw his arms around him and kissed him. The son said to him, "Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you. I am no longer worthy to be called your son." But the father said to his servants, "Quick! Bring the best robe and put it on him. Put a ring on his finger and sandals on his feet. Bring the fattened calf and kill it. Let's have a feast and celebrate. For this son of mine was dead and is alive again; he was lost and is found." So they began to celebrate.

Meanwhile, the older son was in the field. When he came near the house, he heard music and dancing. So he called one of the servants and asked him what was going on. "Your brother has come," he replied, "and your father has killed the fattened calf because he has him back safe and sound." The older brother became angry and refused to go in. So his father went out and pleaded with him. But he answered his father, "Look! All these years I've been slaving for you and never disobeyed your orders. Yet you never gave me even a young goat so I could celebrate with my friends. But when this son of yours who has squandered your property with prostitutes comes home, you kill the fattened calf for him!" "My son," the father said, "you are always with me, and everything I have is yours. But we had to celebrate and be glad, because this brother of yours was dead and is alive again; he was lost and is found." (Luke 15:11-32)

At the end, Mary Alice's comments: "The story always ends the same - in the tender embrace of a loving father."

10 Comments:

Anonymous said...

are you trying to put a good spin on this trashy tv show?

1:37 PM  
Melinda Ledman said...

I'm not sure I'd call it spin. Spin is when you're taking something completely out of context and making it something it wasn't intended to be, just for your own purposes. Actually, this would be more like embellishing. Taking what's already there and exploring it deeper.

That's our hope here at HJ, that people will watch film and television on a deeper level. Desperate Housewives DEEPER, you may say? Yes. If you check out the transcript on this episode (and many other DH episodes), you will see that the writers and producers actually INTENDED to explore the concept of the prodigal son as it relates to the characters in the show. What's so bad about that?

The fact is that most writers don't get their stuff produced unless it has some relevant theme (more true of film than television). Therefore, hands down, you can find SOME kind of theme in every single film out there.

Furthermore, if you think about it, every good story has some element of trashiness - after all, what is sin? And what story is truly good unless it tells of the human condition? We connect to the "trash" in stories - including Bible stories - because we all experience sin on some level or another. The truly GREAT films and tv series set themselves apart by saying something more about that condition. Rather than just feeding us a mindless storyline, they add something to think about...like the story of the prodigal son, for instance.

Check it out. It's very interesting when you start watching for the messages in the stuff you are watching. Some are horrible messages, some are good. The reason this series is such a hit is because people really relate to it. They have exposed my sinful heart on more than one occasion! And my guess is that the writers and producers have something more than "trash" in mind for their series.

9:30 PM  
Melinda Ledman said...

For transcripts, go to: http://desperatehousewives.ahaava.com/episodes.htm

9:33 PM  
Anonymous said...

of course they have something more in mind than trash.....MONEY...if people need to go to the world to find out about the sin in there life then i guess we have no need for the Holy Spirit to convict us....why not encourage folks to read their bibles then to try and find mean in this debased trash on tv....

8:30 AM  
Melinda Ledman said...

I guess I should clarify - I didn't say that people should go into the world to discover their sin. I meant that sin connects us all, it's what makes us human. Trials and struggles in life are what stories are all about. The reality is that those trials and struggles are almost always founded in sin, ours or someone else's that affects us.

Let's take the Bible for instance. Jesus taught in parables, basically stories. Did Jesus's stories tell about people who had no problems whatsoever? Look at the parable of the unmerciful servant, he had pride in his life. The prodigal son, he had rebellion and hatred in his life. How about the rich fool? He loved his money more than life - greed. All I'm saying is that stories are about people and sin and life as we know it here on earth. Jesus told these stories because they revealed sin. Interestingly enough, he didn't explain most of his parables, and he didn't follow them up with an object lesson. He just put them out there for people to interpret.

The whole Bible is like that. Some passages give a "moral," but they are not usually connected to a story. Usually moralistic statements are just that, statements of admonition or encouragement. The stories are just told and left out there. As you pointed out, the Holy Spirit does the work. For the believer, he is convicted of sin. For the non-believer, he sees a need for salvation.

So, how does the help my point? Just that both Christians and non-Christians need to take a deeper look at stories, whether in the Bible or in the theater. I'm not saying people shouldn't read their Bibles. They most certainly should. It's just that most people don't read their Bibles because they don't understand the stories - Christians and non-Christians alike. Learning to interpret stories is a fundamental spiritual discipline.

If a person cannot interpret a story despite it's immoral content, then they have no more business reading the Bible than they do watching DH. Noah's daughters get him drunk and have sex with him so they can procreate - that's incest! What do you do with that story if you can't see beyond the filth - if you can't understand the whole story of redemption in the Bible? There's no fine verse following that story saying, "And by the way, what they did was wrong. They repented to God and committed their lives to better behavior." How about the rapes of the many women in the Bible? How about the violent wars in the Old Testament where God commanded the slaughter of entire civilizations - women and children?

The point is that every story has meaning and it's worth it for every reader or watcher to look for that meaning. If I can be a part of that training process, then I'm proud to take part. If I can teach a non-believer to interpret Desperate Housewives, then perhaps when he sits alone in his bedroom staring at a Bible someone gave him, maybe the Holy Spirit won't have to work so hard to expose the meaning. And if I can teach a Christian to look for meaning in film and television, then he can better connect with his peers about things they are already watching.

And about the money thing, I realize that the studios and financial backers of the media don't have much more in mind than the bottom line. What sells? BUT, the writers and producers often do. If you look into the world of media, you will discover there is a constant war waging between the "artists" and the investors. You will constantly see a writer or producer trying to get something done, and a studio or network coming in and asking them to change their work - because they feel the financial bottom line is more important than the message. In a few wonderful series and films, both the message gets told and the money gets made. But there is a battle waging to be sure.

Hope this helps you see our vision some. Even though you are totally opposed to this series, and I understand that many, many people are, I hope you can at least see how OTHERS may be able to use it to Christ's glory. Check out the link to the Conversation Starters page. It's a good way for Christians and non-Christians to engage one another in spiritual topics that really matter, using the show.

10:02 AM  
Anonymous said...

I dont mean to be argumentative and i appreciate you taking the time to answer these...but I will end with this...God may use somethings in this tv show that may cause people to question their life and may even get someone to think about our Heavenly Father...but there is nothing in this worldy tv show that glorifies God, it does glorify the flesh, adultry, lust and nakedness never glorifies God

2:31 PM  
Melinda Ledman said...

I really appreciate your comments and I don't think you're being argumentative at all. (You've certainly stayed away from any slanderous, hateful personal attacks, which I always appreciate!) I love this kind of talk because it's this kind of conversation that keeps us sharp.

I agree that the show does not have a God-glorifying agenda. There ARE a couple of episodes, however, that discuss Christian topics such as salvation, or here, the prodigal son. And that's the primary reason I try to do a review for each episode. The narrator actually has some pretty compelling commentary on life.

You're right, it's not that writers and directors in Hollywood are trying to teach us anything Christian at all. They would be hung out to dry by their own people for doing so. It's that we have the capacity as thinking Christians to take film and television and use it for something good. WE are the ones who bring glory to God, through the exposition of themes within the stories the world is telling.

This episode of DH is the perfect example. Imagine two viewers in America. One is a person struggling with his or her addiction to pornography. The devil might use this show for evil by provoking lustful thoughts in this struggling person. Or elsewhere in the country, another individual might be sitting in his or her living room thinking, "Hmm...the prod-, prodi, what was that? Prodival, prodibal? son? I've never read that story." Maybe they go look it up online and actually read the story. Or maybe this site comes up and they read the review. Not only have they now read the story, but they've also gotten a pretty clear explanation of the meaning.

It is our ability to connect the Gospel to what folks are already watching that makes HJ so incredibly popular. We average over a million hits per day - people want to make connections. They want to understand the stories they are watching, and if we can bring them around to a clearer understanding of God's love for them, then God HAS been glorified.

Regardless of what this show intends to do, I have the opportunity to bring glory to God by watching it. Sounds contradictory, I know...but I wonder just how many people have read the story of the prodigal son or contemplated God's love since this was posted.

I think everyone has their own call to ministry, and that's why the church is called the body of Christ. Not everyone is a hand, and not everyone is a foot. Some are called to exhort and encourage new Christians to leave their lives of sin. That is a necessary part of the Christian life. Others are called to reach unbelievers. I am called to be a writer. You won't find me on a street corner witnessing, and I won't go door to door. It's not my gift. :)

I'm so glad you wrote and although you will not likely take up a new hobby watching the show, maybe this will inspire you to consider the talent God has given you. Which way to you lean? What are your spiritual gifts? Where are you most effective? Maybe you already know. Either way, God bless you. Hope this dialogue helps you enjoy HJ on a whole new level!

3:22 PM  
Anonymous said...

Thank you Melinda. I follow your comments, but seldom comment. I just want you to know that you are an oasis in a dry and thirsty land! Thanks for bringing a much needed voice. keep on keepin' on Girl! You Go!

8:44 PM  
Amy C. said...

Amen to that! Melinda, it is hard to find women like you! Church people are so lame. But you are different. I believe in God, but I just don't like church. Maybe I'll make this website my church and think of you as my "pastor". My husband is not a believer -But, he likes DH! So we watch together. I am thinking of using your comments as talking points with him. Pray for me/us! Church and all that christian shit is just not in our future.church is hell for me, How is it that you are so different than the typical do-gooders like the one you encountered in the above comments?

7:53 PM  
Melinda Ledman said...

Anonymous and Amy: Thanks so much for the encouragement! Sometimes I wonder if I ever make a dent at all...yes, we writers are sensitive too. I'm adjusting to life with a new baby (our second), trying to get the post partum weight off, and staying so busy that I can't seem to focus some days - and really, that's not half of the story! And in all of that, I get discouraged like everyone. Some days, I look at the computer and think, "Does anyone even read these things?" LOL! But, thanks for the encouragement. We all need it at different times, and it seems like that time is now for me. Thanks so much for your comments!

Amy: Interestingly, I'm a church person. :) I grew up in church, but as a teenager, I went the other direction. I got into alcoholism (spent 12 years drunk as a skunk) and many other horrible things that go along with that addiction. But when I encountered Christ on a real level (not the sermon in church level, but the sitting-in-a-closet-with-a-bottle-in-your-hand kind of desperation), life changed forever for me. There is something about acknowledging your own sins and being forgiven for them that makes you a lot more liberal. Once you see what you're capable of, it's hard to accuse anyone else. And once you are forgiven in a way that you feel you can move on (like Jesus and the Samaritan woman at the well), you just don't want to beat anyone down about what they've done. You'd rather share hope with them. The same hope you experienced. That's where I come from. That's why no one can make me ashamed of Christ - Read Psalm 40:2-3.

The other thing is that I've been a Bible-beater, humorously enough, while I was a drunk! I've been the hypocrite, and honestly, I feel as much empathy for them as I feel for my fellow addict. The problem with all of us is that we don't want to admit we've all got crap to deal with. Many church people hide behind a facade of good behavior. Addicts hide behind their addictions. Workaholics hide behind their desks. Nobody talks on a deeper level, and we all miss out on seeing what God can do. That's what I admire about the "do-gooder" from above. He or she was willing to talk it out, get down to it and think outside the box. Even if we ultimately choose to agree to disagree, I'm impressed that they chatted for so long. Most would just drop it after realizing I wasn't going to conform. I respect that a lot, and think that if more Christians would have the patience to listen and talk, we'd all be a lot more down to earth.

As for church, I still go. But it's because I took the time to find one where people talk about their issues. They (these kinds of churches) really do exist, you just have to work a little harder to find them. I've been to many where they never scratched the surface of anything, but I won't settle for that. I go because I need mentors. Fact is, I'm just as weak and frail as I ever was - it's just that my sins are more internal than external. I still need support. I still need people who have been Christians longer to help me figure out how what to do with my mess. I go to the Bible first, because God seems to know it all. ;) But when I can't see the forest for the trees and I know I need help, I go ask someone who's been there. That's what I get out of church.

But to each his own. If church isn't for you right now, don't fool with it. Just keep a Bible handy and talk to people you like. I got my church services inside the walls of AA for many years. You take what you can, learn where you can, do what you can when you can, and let the rest go. God is the captain of your ship, and he's taking you on the journey that's right for you. I trust he knows what he's doing!

Wow! Did I get on a soapbox or what?? LOL! Thanks so much again for the encouragement. I will definitely pray for you and your hubby. Real life is where it all starts. Sometimes that just means eating chocolate chip cookies in front of the television together and talking about stories! (My hubby and I have had MANY of those nights) God bless!

8:25 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home