Sunday, February 20, 2005

Born Into Brothels

Overview
Spiritual Connections

"When I have a camera in my hands I feel happy. I feel like I am learning something...I can be someone."
-Suchitra (one of the children in Born Into Brothels)

Click to enlargePhotojournalist Zana Briski wanted to capture in pictures the hard life of prostitutes in Calcutta. She lived with them to gain their trust. In the process, she met their children who were growing up with no hope of a better life. Indeed, the girls would most likely soon be “joining the line.” The boys would likely become pimps or addicts.

These are children that our phrase “at risk” doesn’t even come close to describing. Where could they go to escape? Schools and agencies weren’t interested because their mothers (and sometimes even grandmothers and great-grandmothers) were sex workers. Even to get a passport was nearly impossible. These were children that most people would prefer didn’t exist.

Born Into Brothels shows us not just the lives of these children, but the hope that came into their world through the work and passion of Zana Briski. Briski brought point-and-shoot cameras for a group of the children and gave them instruction in the art of photography. Many of the photographs these children took of the streets of Calcutta are truly works of art.

Of course cameras in themselves are not enough to bring hope or change into these children’s lives. Briski also spent a good deal of time trying to find schools that would take some of the children. Now there is Kids With Cameras, an organization that is seeking to build a school for the children of the sex workers in Calcutta, and is expanding its work to other areas as well. Because of the work started by giving these children cameras, there is hope that some of them may find a new life with far more fulfilling possibilities.

While the film does show us some of Briski’s dedication on behalf of the children, it really concentrates on the children themselves, their setting, and their growth as they begin to take pictures. Through their photography they begin to see themselves as something more than the human detritus that the world has treated them as. They become very capable photographers, capturing the world around them not like most of us do when we take our cameras on vacation, but showing the combination of beauty and pathos that makes up their lives.

Throughout the film we see many of the amazing photographs the children took. Eventually, some of the photos were auctioned at Sotheby’s. Amnesty International featured their photos in its 2003 calendar. The Kids With Cameras website has prints available for purchase as well as a companion book of the film. (Proceeds go to support the children’s education.)

A few (but sadly not all) of these children do indeed escape the squalor of their lives in the brothels. It is the success of those few that gives this film its sense of hope that lives can truly be changed by those, like Briski, who care enough for others to share of themselves. Her relationship with the children means far more than the cameras and classes she taught. She taught them to believe in themselves through her believing in them. By believing in themselves, they can begin to see the possibilities life can hold for them. Those possibilities are the essence of hope.

This film will slowly be making its way around the country in the spring of 2005. As the flowers begin to bloom in the world around us, this film can help hope bloom in our lives as we see the ways that lives touching others can bring beauty into even the darkest and dreariest settings.

Overview
Spiritual Connections

4 Comments:

dan said...

darrel,

do you know these people? i am watching the awards on TV
i have one question. i feel Zana Briski of BORN INTO BROTHELS award was scandalous in that she appeared
at the awards ceremony looking like a hooker herself! and the movie is
supposred to tell people the sadness and dangers of prostitiution via
the kids, and yet she appears with her own breatsts hanging out of her
dress like a hooker. it ruined the award for me. i feel she should
have dressed more conservatrively. you don't win friends that way.
what do you think?>


jeez, she could have dressed with a better PR message. as it looks
now, she is just a gold digger slut. that kind of outfit was
denigrating to the people she documented. what on earth was going on
in her head.

i want to email her and tell her face to face. do u know her email address?

dont get me wrong. i love what she and ross accomplished. i salute
the, and i know they are good people. but i am a PR nut from way back
and i feel she blew her chance for understand. how could she be so
DUMB? or insensitive.? there is a world beyond hollywood, watching.

sigh.

and this:

from an Indian national:

> First of all I have not seen this film BROITHELK KIDS so I would not comment about
> the film-making/art aspect of it.
>
> However, I read about the film and honestly find it pretty pathetic.
>
> Looks like the film-makers are trying to follow the well established
> path: Pick up one wretched corner of the developing world, picture the
> misery of the people and use them for personal gains and throw in
> couple of western (white) characters and show them as saviors of the
> poor 'third-world' souls.
>
> Its true that some Westerners actually do things to help these people
> but vast majority just love to talk about these issues in parties
> particularly the guilt-ridden, patronizing liberal ones. The
> film-makers goes at length to show the bureaucracy in Kolkata schools
> but don't bother to even mention literally hundreds of Indian social
> organizations that play important role in protecting the existing
> prostitutes and rehabilitating others. Kolkata in particular is very
> active in terms of welfare of prostitutes. Prostitutes in Kolkata are
> organized in union and they enjoy legal protection and the spread of
> AIDS is minimal due to active health-care programs. Of course, the
> film-makers won't show it because the people doing real work are not
> westerners, they are Indians. If someone is making a documentary film
> it should be factual not a fairy tale story of white angels saving
> poor and dark people.
>
> This is exactly the same reason Hotel Rwanda won't get the Oscar
> because the heroes of the film are black Africans not westerners.
>
> In any case, the film-makers have a right to make any film they want.
> As long as they don't exploit poor children of the 'third-world' for
> making money its okay. Local media in Kolkata says that the
> film-makers raised false hope among the children and they are worse
> off after taking part in the film. If the film-makers are so desperate
> to picture misery maybe they should take their camera to the
> inner-city slums of New York and picture the troubled and often
> criminalized kids of those neighborhoods. Lets see how much people
> enjoy that! If you really want to watch a good film about poor kids
> living in many slums in urban India, watch "Salaam Bombay" by Mira
> Nair. Its an excellent film but unlike this one does not portray slum
> kids as weak, poor and dependent on western generosity. It depicts the
> reality about how actually the slum kids fight for their survival and
> fight against incredible odds.

6:31 AM  
Whitney, 17 y/o, and Annoyed. said...

I think you should watch Born Into Brothels before making such assertions. Zana Briski devoted nearly her entire adult life thus far to that district, and while I agree with the general sentiment about white exploitation of third world contexts, I think you're wrong on this one. The children are NOT portrayed as "dependent on western generosity", nor did the filmakers make much money on this film. And I've seen Salaam Bombay. It's O.K... I'm perplexed by the energy you have to immediately critique a movie you haven't seen. Seems like you're looking for truths to prove a point rather than points to prove a truth...

3:19 PM  
raj101 said...

This post has been removed by the author.

9:35 PM  
raj101 said...

I am an indian national living in Phoenix, AZ for a short while. The comments above about Zana Briski is sad. I saw born in to brothels and salam bombay. Both are excellent works. To the indian guy posted above, why the heck you want to bring the color and racism into this? What did you do to help those kids? If you are not doing anything, at least dont discourage those who does. I appreciate Zana's works and thank her for that. And anybody who reads this, please understand there is lot of silent people in india who appreciate what Zana does and did. And anybody who does something, like Zana, they have to skip lot of jerks like the one above to get something done. Remember the 'ration guys' in born in the brothels?

9:39 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home